Today, the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments in Mahmoud v. Taylor, a case about religious parents who don’t want their children to be taught about LGBTQ+ people in public schools. The conservative justices seemed to side with the religious parents, but a lawyer for the schools argued that it’s unrealistic to allow parents to opt-out of any lessons they personally disagree with.
The plaintiffs in the case objected to their children being read books at storytime like Love, Violet, a 2021 children’s picture book about a shy girl who has a crush on her classmate, and Uncle Bobby’s Wedding, a 2025 picture book about a male same-sex wedding.
The religious parents objected to the books, saying that the books infringe on their First Amendment rights to not have their children taught about gender and sexuality in ways that conflict with their religious beliefs.